Au Pair vs Nanny: Costs, Pros & Cons Compared

Both au pairs and nannies provide in-home child care, but the similarities end there. Au pairs are young adults from abroad participating in a cultural exchange program; nannies are domestic employees you hire directly. The differences in cost, flexibility, experience level, and family impact are significant.

This comprehensive guide compares every aspect of au pairs and nannies, helping you determine which option best fits your family's needs, budget, and lifestyle.

Au Pairs: Understanding the Basics

What Is an Au Pair?

An au pair is a young adult (18-26 years old) from another country who lives with a host family for up to two years while providing child care. The program is regulated by the U.S. Department of State as a cultural exchange program—child care is part of the exchange, not the primary purpose.

Key characteristics:

• Lives in your home (private room required)
• Provides up to 45 hours of child care per week
• Receives weekly stipend (currently $195.75 minimum)
• Here for cultural exchange, not employment
• Must have visa and work through sponsoring agency

How the Au Pair Program Works

The process:

1. Choose a State Department-designated sponsoring agency
2. Create family profile and review candidate profiles
3. Interview and match with au pair candidates
4. Agency handles visa and travel arrangements
5. Au pair arrives and completes orientation
6. Au pair lives with your family for 12 months (extendable to 24)

Program requirements (for families):

• Provide private bedroom for au pair
• Provide meals or food stipend
• Pay weekly stipend ($195.75+ minimum)
• Allow at least 1.5 days off per week
• Provide educational allowance ($500) for courses
• Include au pair in family activities
• Have children under 18 in the home

Au pair requirements:

• Age 18-26
• Secondary education completed
• Proficient in English
• Pass medical exams
• Pass background screening
• At least 200 hours of child care experience
• Valid driver's license (for most placements)

Au Pair Costs Breakdown

| Cost Category | Typical Amount | Notes | |---------------|----------------|-------| | Agency program fee | $7,500-$9,500 | Paid annually, covers matching and support | | Weekly stipend | $195.75 × 52 = $10,179/year | Minimum required by law | | Room and board | $3,000-$8,000/year | Estimated value of room, food | | Educational allowance | $500 | Required contribution toward college courses | | Additional costs | $500-$2,000 | Phone, car usage, activities | | Total annual cost | $22,000-$30,000 | All-in cost including room/board |

Compared to nanny: While the cash outlay may seem similar to some nanny salaries, au pair costs are fixed and predictable regardless of location. In high-cost areas, au pairs are often significantly cheaper than nannies.

Nannies: Understanding the Basics

What Is a Nanny?

A nanny is a professional child care provider you employ directly to care for your children, either in your home (live-out nanny) or as a household member (live-in nanny). Unlike au pairs, nannies are domestic employees subject to employment laws.

Key characteristics:

• Professional child care provider
• Works set hours (typically 40-55 per week)
• Paid hourly or salary as employee
• May live in or out
• No program restrictions—negotiate directly

How Hiring a Nanny Works

The process:

1. Define your needs (hours, duties, qualifications)
2. Recruit through agencies, websites, or referrals
3. Interview, background check, verify references
4. Make offer and negotiate terms
5. Set up payroll (you are the employer)
6. Onboard and manage ongoing relationship

Your obligations as employer:

• Pay at least minimum wage (often much more)
• Withhold and pay employment taxes
• Provide workers' compensation insurance
• Comply with overtime laws
• Issue W-2 at year end
• May need to provide benefits

Nanny Costs Breakdown

| Cost Category | Low/Mid Market | High-Cost Metro | Notes | |---------------|----------------|-----------------|-------| | Gross salary | $35,000-$50,000 | $55,000-$80,000 | Varies hugely by location | | Employer taxes | $3,500-$5,000 | $5,500-$8,000 | ~10% of gross salary | | Benefits | $0-$5,000 | $3,000-$10,000 | Health, PTO, etc. | | Payroll service | $500-$1,200 | $500-$1,200 | Optional but recommended | | Agency fee (if used) | $2,000-$5,000 | $5,000-$12,000 | One-time, 10-20% of salary | | Total annual cost | $40,000-$60,000 | $65,000-$100,000+ | Wide range by location |

Live-in nannies: May accept lower salary (10-20% less) in exchange for room and board, but still significantly more than au pairs in most markets.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Cost Comparison

| Factor | Au Pair | Nanny | |--------|---------|-------| | Total annual cost | $22,000-$30,000 | $40,000-$100,000+ | | Cost varies by location? | No (fixed program) | Yes, dramatically | | Overtime for extra hours? | No | Yes (legally required) | | Agency fees | Annual program fee | One-time placement fee | | Benefits costs | Minimal (education only) | Can be significant |

Bottom line: Au pairs are typically 30-60% less expensive than nannies, with the savings most dramatic in high-cost cities.

Experience and Qualifications

| Factor | Au Pair | Nanny | |--------|---------|-------| | Minimum age | 18 | No minimum | | Child care experience | 200+ hours required | Varies; can require years | | Training/credentials | Orientation training only | Can require ECE degree, certifications | | Driving | License required | Often required, negotiate | | English proficiency | Required, varies | Native or fluent | | Specialized experience | Limited (special needs au pairs exist) | Can find infant, special needs, etc. |

Bottom line: Nannies offer the potential for significantly more experience and specialized qualifications. Au pairs are young adults with limited experience.

Flexibility and Hours

| Factor | Au Pair | Nanny | |--------|---------|-------| | Maximum weekly hours | 45 (strict limit) | Negotiate (with overtime) | | Maximum daily hours | 10 | Negotiate | | Overtime | Not permitted | Required at 1.5× rate | | Scheduling flexibility | Must have 1.5 days off | Negotiate | | Weekend/overnight care | Limited hours count toward 45 | Can negotiate | | Travel with family | Possible (some restrictions) | Can negotiate |

Bottom line: Nannies offer more flexibility on hours but cost more. Au pairs are limited to 45 hours maximum—no exceptions.

Living Arrangements

| Factor | Au Pair | Nanny | |--------|---------|-------| | Living situation | Must live with family | Live-in or live-out | | Room requirement | Private bedroom required | If live-in, private space | | Meals | Included | Typically included if live-in | | Privacy | Au pair is part of family | More separation possible | | Cultural exchange | Expected—include in activities | Optional |

Bottom line: Au pairs are always live-in and become part of your household. Nannies can be live-in or live-out, offering more flexibility for family privacy.

Continuity and Commitment

| Factor | Au Pair | Nanny | |--------|---------|-------| | Typical duration | 12-24 months max | Open-ended | | Transition frequency | New au pair every 1-2 years | Can stay for years | | Notice required | 2 weeks minimum | Per contract (often 2-4 weeks) | | Replacement support | Agency helps with rematch | You handle | | Consistency for children | Regular changes | Potentially more stable |

Bottom line: Nannies can provide long-term continuity. Au pairs are inherently temporary, requiring transition every 1-2 years.

Pros and Cons

Au Pair: Advantages

For your family:

• Significantly lower cost, especially in high-cost areas
• Flexible scheduling within 45 hours
• Cultural enrichment for children
• Language exposure (if different native language)
• Agency support for issues and transitions
• Fixed, predictable costs
• Travel flexibility for family trips

For your children:

• Live-in care means morning/evening availability
• Exposure to different cultures and perspectives
• Potential language learning
• Young, energetic caregiver

Au Pair: Potential Drawbacks

Consider carefully:

• Limited experience—young adults, not professionals
• Annual transitions disrupt children and family
• Must provide private bedroom (housing cost)
• Less privacy—someone lives with you
• 45-hour limit may not cover full-time work needs
• Cultural/communication challenges possible
• Au pair may get homesick or struggle with adjustment
• You become a mentor/host, not just employer

Deal-breakers for some:

• Need more than 45 hours weekly
• No private bedroom available
• Need specialized care (infants, special needs)
• Want long-term continuity
• Uncomfortable with live-in arrangement

Nanny: Advantages

For your family:

• Professional child care experience
• Can hire for specialized needs
• Flexible hours (with appropriate pay)
• Long-term relationship possible
• Live-out option maintains privacy
• More predictable skills and approach
• Direct employment relationship

For your children:

• Potentially years with same caregiver
• Professional training and experience
• Consistency in care and expectations
• Specialized skills available (infant care, special needs)

Nanny: Potential Drawbacks

Consider carefully:

• Significantly higher cost
• Employer responsibilities (taxes, insurance)
• You manage the relationship directly
• Finding a good match takes significant effort
• No backup if nanny is sick
• Wide range in quality—harder to evaluate
• May need to provide benefits

Which Is Right for Your Family?

Choose an Au Pair If:

Your situation:

• You have a private bedroom to offer
• You need up to 45 hours of care per week (not more)
• You're comfortable with a live-in arrangement
• Your children are past infancy (2+)
• You don't require specialized experience
• You value cultural exchange for your children

Your budget:

• Au pair fits your budget better than nanny
• You're in a high-cost area where nanny costs are extreme
• You prefer fixed, predictable costs

Your flexibility:

• You can handle caregiver transitions every 1-2 years
• You're willing to be a host family, not just employer
• You're comfortable mentoring a young adult

Choose a Nanny If:

Your situation:

• You need more than 45 hours of care weekly
• You have an infant or child with special needs
• You want a live-out arrangement
• You don't have a private room available
• You prioritize experience and qualifications
• You want long-term consistency

Your budget:

• You can afford nanny costs in your area
• You're comfortable being an employer
• You want to provide benefits

Your flexibility:

• You prefer a professional relationship
• You want to define exactly what you need
• You value stability over cultural exchange

Consider Both If:

• Your needs are in the "middle ground"
• You're weighing cost vs. experience trade-offs
• You're open to either approach depending on the specific candidate

Special Considerations

Infant Care

Au pairs and infants:

• Generally not recommended as sole care for infants under 3 months
• Agencies may require additional infant training
• Less experience with newborn care
• 45-hour limit challenging with infant needs

Recommendation: For infants, especially under 6 months, a nanny with infant experience is often the better choice.

Multiple Children

Au pairs with multiple children:

• Can care for several children within 45 hours
• Cost doesn't increase with number of children
• May be overwhelmed with many young children
• Great value for families with 2-4 kids

Nannies with multiple children:

• Pay typically increases per additional child ($2-5/hour more)
• More experience handling multiple children
• Better for complex schedules (different schools, activities)

Recommendation: For cost, au pairs with multiple children is excellent value. For complexity, nannies may handle it better.

Special Needs

Au pairs for special needs:

• Limited experience with special needs
• "Extraordinaire" au pair program for qualified au pairs
• Additional training and slightly higher fees
• Still limited compared to specialized nanny

Nannies for special needs:

• Can find nannies with specific experience
• Specialized training available
• Better for complex medical or behavioral needs
• Higher cost for specialized skills

Recommendation: For significant special needs, a specialized nanny is typically the better choice.

Travel and Extended Hours

Au pairs and travel:

• Can travel with family (hours still limited)
• Vacation time still counts toward stipend weeks
• Some program restrictions on travel

Au pairs and occasional extended hours:

• Cannot exceed 45 weekly hours, period
• No overtime flexibility
• May need backup care for occasional needs

Nannies and flexibility:

• Overnight, travel, weekend care possible
• Overtime pay required but no hour limits
• More adaptable to variable schedules

Recommendation: If you regularly need 50+ hours or variable extended hours, nanny is the better fit.

Making the Transition

From Nanny to Au Pair

If considering switching to au pair:

• Ensure you have private bedroom
• Prepare children for transition and cultural differences
• Understand the mentorship role you'll take on
• Plan for the adjustment period (culture, communication)
• Consider overlap period with outgoing nanny

From Au Pair to Nanny

If considering switching to nanny:

• Budget for increased costs
• Prepare for employer responsibilities
• Decide on live-in vs. live-out
• Start search before current au pair departs
• Understand different relationship dynamic

Combining Both

Some families use:

• Au pair for primary care, nanny share for backup
• Au pair during school year, nanny for summer
• Au pair for day hours, babysitter for occasional nights

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I hire an au pair for infant twins?

A: Technically yes, but it's challenging. Most agencies recommend waiting until infants are 3+ months, and caring for two infants simultaneously is demanding for an inexperienced caregiver. Consider a nanny for the infant stage, transitioning to au pair later.

Q: What if my au pair isn't working out?

A: Contact your sponsoring agency. They can mediate issues and, if necessary, facilitate a "rematch"—finding a new family for your au pair and a new au pair for your family. This process typically takes 2-4 weeks.

Q: Do I really have to include my au pair in family activities?

A: Yes, it's expected as part of the cultural exchange. Au pairs should be treated as family members, invited to family dinners, outings, and celebrations. If you want a purely professional, separate relationship, a live-out nanny is the better choice.

Q: What's the tax situation for au pairs vs. nannies?

A: Au pair stipends are not subject to employment taxes (Social Security, Medicare) since au pairs are J-1 cultural exchange visitors, not employees. Nannies are employees, and you must pay employer taxes (~10% of salary) and handle withholding.

Q: Can an au pair drive my children?

A: Yes, most au pairs can and do drive. They must have a valid license, and most families add them to car insurance. Driving ability is a common requirement when matching. Some families provide a car; others share a family vehicle.

Q: How do I find a good au pair or nanny?

A: For au pairs, choose a reputable sponsoring agency (Cultural Care, AuPairCare, InterExchange are large agencies) and take time interviewing candidates. For nannies, use agencies, Care.com, or referrals, and conduct thorough background checks and reference calls.

Conclusion

The au pair vs. nanny decision comes down to weighing trade-offs:

| Au Pair | Nanny | |---------|-------| | Lower cost | Higher experience | | Live-in required | Live-in or out | | 45-hour maximum | Flexible hours | | Annual transitions | Long-term potential | | Cultural exchange | Professional relationship |

Neither is inherently better. Au pairs are an excellent value for families who can accommodate live-in care, don't need more than 45 hours, and embrace cultural exchange. Nannies are worth the investment for families needing flexibility, specialized experience, or long-term continuity.

Evaluate your specific needs, budget, and lifestyle—then choose the option that serves your family best.

---

Exploring all your in-home care options? Check out our guides on how to hire a nanny, nanny costs, nanny vs. daycare, and managing your nanny.